Seibertron.com Energon Pub Forums

If they had better cartoons, toys or if there were better storylines or animation or if the characters were better? If the Rock Lords have never been invented?

Did you see how the Japanese presented their version of Gobots in their 47 episode Machine Robo Revenge of Cronos?

They basically used the same products in CotGB. Maybe Hasbro and Marvel caught the lightning in the bottle back then.........or as in "Highlander" parlance, "There can be only One"

The GoBots needed a better animated series and names. The toys were fine, and in some cases are better than Trasformers of comparable size and price at the time.

babylon queen wrote:If they had better cartoons, toys or if there were better storylines or animation or if the characters were better? If the Rock Lords have never been invented?

The cartoon would have been a good start if done right. However, Tonka made the mistake of trying to rush things by contracting Hanna-Barbera. Although they were the master in keeping animation cheap yet effective, they didn't have much expertise in the Action/Adventure genre. Importing Machine Robo: Revenge of Cronos would not have worked, just for the reason it came a few years too late (1986) to make a difference. It did get a sequel series, Machine Robo: Battle Hackers (which got canceled at 31 episodes) and some OVA's, but they all had the same Robo with some new ones. Not enough to make a good difference. Both did feature the Rock Lords, with the Fossil Lords as primary protagonists in the later series.

Down to the toys themselves, the Machine Robo have their charm, especially if they have die cast metal. And they were diverse and willing to experiment with the Big, DX, W and Combiners (I wanted Puzzler...) for starters. Ultimately they were for the most part more simplistic in style compared to Takara's offerings. There are some gems in there though. Tonka's own designs... don't get me started

So yeah, it could have been done much better if it was done just a tad slower and with a bit more forethought. The turtle always wins the race, as Hasbro has proven.

babylon queen wrote:If they had better cartoons, toys or if there were better storylines or animation or if the characters were better? If the Rock Lords have never been invented?

It's funny because the question and the answer are the same thing. "Would Go-bots have been better if it was better?"

JelZe GoldRabbit wrote:

babylon queen wrote:If they had better cartoons, toys or if there were better storylines or animation or if the characters were better? If the Rock Lords have never been invented?

The cartoon would have been a good start if done right. However, Tonka made the mistake of trying to rush things by contracting Hanna-Barbera. Although they were the master in keeping animation cheap yet effective, they didn't have much expertise in the Action/Adventure genre. Importing Machine Robo: Revenge of Cronos would not have worked, just for the reason it came a few years too late (1986) to make a difference. It did get a sequel series, Machine Robo: Battle Hackers (which got canceled at 31 episodes) and some OVA's, but they all had the same Robo with some new ones. Not enough to make a good difference. Both did feature the Rock Lords, with the Fossil Lords as primary protagonists in the later series.

Down to the toys themselves, the Machine Robo have their charm, especially if they have die cast metal. And they were diverse and willing to experiment with the Big, DX, W and Combiners (I wanted Puzzler...) for starters. Ultimately they were for the most part more simplistic in style compared to Takara's offerings. There are some gems in there though. Tonka's own designs... don't get me started

So yeah, it could have been done much better if it was done just a tad slower and with a bit more forethought. The turtle always wins the race, as Hasbro has proven.

Puzzler? I really wanted that Devastator wannabee! The components iirc had die-cast frames (car body and not the robot torsos as in the Stunticons) and rubber tires! If that was implemented with the Stunticons.............mmmmmmmm, I get the goose pimples thinking what could have been.

I heard that for a while the Go-Bots where much more popular than the TF, but the distribution of the toys was terrible and Hasbro had much better and aggressive marketing, even going so far as advertising TFs in Go-Bots comics and during their cartoon's time slot.

So yeah, Go-Bots would have been better had they been better.

Shadowman wrote:It's funny because the question and the answer are the same thing. "Would Go-bots have been better if it was better?"

i was thinking the same thing

babylon queen wrote:If they had better cartoons...

babylon queen wrote:If they had better toys...

babylon queen wrote:If there were better storylines...

babylon queen wrote:If there were better animation...

babylon queen wrote:If the characters were better...

babylon queen wrote:If the Rock Lords have never been invented...